Garnishment

What is a Garnishment

Garnishment is a process that businesses must follow when they receive a legal order to withhold part of an employee’s wages to pay off that employee’s debt. The business acts as an intermediary, deducting specified amounts from the employee’s paycheck and sending it directly to the creditor or government agency. This could be for debts such as unpaid taxes, child support, student loans, or court judgments.

The obligation continues until the employee’s debt is fully paid or the order is lifted. Compliance with garnishment orders is mandatory for employers, failing which they may face penalties.

Why it matters

Garnishment is regulated by the Federal and State laws, specifying the amount that can be garnished from an employee’s wages. It creates a legal obligation for businesses and must be handled with accuracy to ensure compliance. When a garnishment order is issued, deduction of the correct amount, from an employee’s wages, and forwarding it to the designated agency or creditor becomes the responsibility of the employer. Therefore, businesses must carefully calculate the correct amount.

Garnishment directly affects employees. Therefore, how a business handles the process can impact workplace trust and morale. Because an affected employee may already be under financial stress, maintaining transparent communication and accurate payroll processing can reduce confusion and further strain.

Although garnishment does not involve the company’s own debts, it creates administrative responsibilities for payroll and HR departments. Through proper management of garnishment, businesses can not only ensure compliance with the Federal and State regulations, but also demonstrate fairness, reliability, and respect for both the law and their workforce. By treating garnishment as an important administrative responsibility, businesses can strengthen their reputation as responsible employers.

Eliminate time theft and buddy punching

Get hourly time tracking and PTO management!

Use cases

Garnishment is important for businesses, especially small and mid-sized businesses with 10-500 employees because they often operate with limited payroll and HR teams, yet must comply with all legal obligations. With proper handling of garnishment orders, these small businesses can avoid penalties or legal action that can even impact their existence.

For instance, in a small construction company with around 70 employees, garnishment cases can arise due to the workforce being a mix of permanent staff, independent contractors, and seasonal workers. Because the company may work on projects that are labor-intensive and involve a movable workforce, efficient mobile workforce management and accurate garnishment calculation for employees or full-time equivalents, can help meet the requirements of the State laws while also maintaining labor law compliance.

A dental clinic, with a small team of 50 members, may face unique garnishment challenges because administrative staff often juggle multiple responsibilities, from patient billing to check payroll processing. In the event of a garnishment order coming in, the clinic must dedicate time and resources to ensure accurate deductions and timely submissions. With limited staff members, the clinic must streamline garnishment handling to avoid errors that could lead to non-compliance or employee morale.

An accounting firm, with around 100 employees, can ensure accuracy in its own automated payroll services by carefully handling garnishments. Since this firm advises clients on financial compliance, it can use proper garnishment handling to demonstrate sound payroll practices internally. Further by strictly adhering to the rules, the firm not only can ensure compliance but also improve credibility and professional reputation.

In a retail franchise, with about 200 employees consisting of hourly workers, the likelihood of receiving garnishment orders is high. Payroll teams must track garnishments for multiple employees while staying within legal limits for deductions. This becomes especially important when this franchise expands across locations, as consistency in handling garnishments can prove critical in avoiding legal issues and maintaining employee confidence.

Legal considerations for compliance

Garnishment orders mean businesses must navigate strict legal requirements. Employers are mandated to follow garnishment orders exactly as issued, as failure to comply can result in fines, liability for the unpaid amount, or legal action against the business.

Key legal considerations include:

• Federal Wage Garnishment Law (Consumer Credit Protection Act, Title III): Limits the amount of disposable earnings that can be garnished and prohibits employers from firing an employee solely because of one garnishment order.
• State-Specific Laws: Some States impose lower garnishment limits or provide additional protections, which businesses must follow, if applicable.
• Multiple Garnishments: To ensure the most critical obligations are met first according to legal requirements, employers must prioritize certain orders, such as child support or tax debts, when multiple garnishments are in place.
• Timely Remittance: Businesses must send the withheld amounts to the correct agency or creditor within the required deadlines; late payments may result in penalties or liability for the business itself.
• Employee Rights: Employees must be notified of garnishments and retain the right to contest them in court.

Looking for payroll and HR?

Get a demo today!

Considerations affecting garnishment

While straightforward in concept, garnishment orders can create significant administrative and compliance responsibilities for employers. There are several factors that can influence how garnishment is handled. Some common considerations include:

• Type of Debt: Garnishments may stem from child support, unpaid taxes, student loans, or court judgments, each with its own rules, affecting the order of priority and the amount to be withheld.
• Multiple Garnishments: When subjected to more than one garnishment order at a time, businesses must determine the orders that should take precedence and calculate remaining amounts within legal limits.
• Varying State Laws: Some States may have stricter garnishment limits than the Federal law. Businesses must apply the law that offers greater protection to the employee.
• Employee Pay Structure: Hourly workers, salaried employees, independent contractors, and those with bonuses or commissions may require different garnishment calculations, making payroll accuracy critical to avoid under- or over-withholding.
• Administrative Resources: Smaller businesses may lack dedicated payroll staff, which can increase the risk of compliance errors if systems or processes are not well managed.
• Confidentiality: Garnishment involves sensitive financial and legal information about employees. Therefore, businesses must handle it discreetly to protect privacy and maintain trust.

Common misunderstandings

Garnishment involves legal orders, and misinterpretations may result in underpayment, overpayment, or violations of employee rights. This can lead to compliance risks and workplace tension. Some common misunderstandings include:

• Garnishment Is Optional for Employers: Garnishment is a legal obligation and if businesses choose to ignore or not follow the order, it can result in penalties.
• The Employer Pays the Debt: The debt is the responsibility of the employee as the employer is just a facilitator that withholds wages and forwards them to the creditor as required.
• Any Amount Can Be Taken from Wages: Garnishments from an employee’s paycheck cannot be withheld at will, as Federal and State laws specify strict limits on how much can be garnished to protect workers’ minimum wage or income.
• Employees Can Be Fired for Garnishment: The Federal law prohibits termination due to a single garnishment order.
• All Garnishments Work the Same Way: Not all garnishments are the same. They have specific requirements and priorities such as child support, taxes, student loans, and other debts.

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

Handling garnishments requires accuracy, timeliness, and compliance, yet many businesses fall into common pitfalls that can create financial and legal risks. Here’s how small and mid-sized businesses can understand and avoid common pitfalls:

• Missing Deadlines for Remittance: To prevent delay in sending garnished wages to the creditor or agency, businesses should set up automated reminders or payroll system alerts.
• Incorrect Withholding Amounts: Use payroll software that accounts for Federal and State rules to avoid over- or under-withholding due to errors in calculating payroll taxes, disposable income or applying limits, and ensure accuracy.
• Ignoring State-Specific Rules: In addition to the Federal laws, regularly review State and local regulations to update payroll policies accordingly and prevent compliance gaps.
• Mishandling Multiple Orders: Instead of treating multiple garnishments equally, prioritize legally mandated ones, such as child support. Maintain clear procedures for order priority to prevent misallocation.
• Failing to Protect Employee Confidentiality: Restrict access to sensitive information within HR and payroll to safeguard employee trust and avoid workplace tension.
• Not Training Payroll Staff: Avoid mishandling of orders by providing ongoing training to ensure employees stay updated on garnishment laws and procedures.

How Fingercheck helps  

Fingercheck simplifies the garnishment process for small and mid-sized businesses by automating wage deductions and ensuring compliance with both Federal and State regulations. Instead of relying on manual calculations, the Fingercheck platform applies garnishment limits correctly, prioritizes multiple orders where necessary, and processes payments directly to creditors or agencies. This reduces the risk of errors, missed deadlines, and penalties, while also relieving payroll teams from time-consuming administrative work. Learn more, contact Fingercheck now!

Fingercheck and any related entities do not offer tax, accounting, or legal advice. This content is designed for informational purposes only and should not be considered a source of tax, legal, or accounting advice. It is recommended that you consult your tax, legal, and accounting advisors before undertaking any related activities or transactions.